| Keith Wynn | Inspector Japp – Scotland Yard inspector, overseeing the investigation. |
| Izabella Fanshier | Constable – Local constable, somewhat bumbling but well-meaning. |
| Chad Hembree | Vicar – Local parish Vicar, involved in a close relationship with Annie. |
| Edwin Tait | Roger Havering – Nephew of Harrington Pace, husband to Zoe. |
| Letha Hembree | Captain Harriet Hastings – Poirot’s partner investigator. |
| Sophia Shepherd | Annie – Maid at Hunter’s Lodge, closely mentored by the Vicar. |
| Laura Day | Eleanor Cartwright – The family lawyer, daughter of Harrington Pace’s lifelong attorney |
| Seth Blackburn | Hercule Poirot – Famous Belgian detective. |
| Paula Davis | Zoe Havering – Wife of Roger, actress-turned-housewife, also poses as Mrs. Middleton. |
| Kaitlyn Longwith | Innkeeper – Runs the village inn, friendly and helpful. |
Mystery at Hunter’s Lodge Cast 2024